Spirits Club O Collection 5 July 2021

The best aged rums to suit every budget

Joel Harrison introduces a category that represents arguably the pinnacle of rum bottlings, before casting his eye over a range of current offerings
Introduction and recommendations by
Photography by

Rum has undergone something of an image makeover in the past decade or so. Where once it was a drink seemingly tied to the high seas – be that through its association with the British Royal Navy, the ‘fifteen men on a dead man’s chest / Yo-ho-ho and a bottle of rum’ pirate adventures from Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island, or the island-style cocktails served in tiki bars such as Trader Vic’s – rum has evolved into a serious sipping spirit. 

Much of the transformation has been inspired by the playbooks of whisky and brandy. For where the likes of Scotch and Cognac have their distinct geographical indicators of flavour, so too does the world of rum. And as with whisky, rum relies on the instruments involved in production to dictate the final flavour of the spirit. Be it copper pot stills (or even wooden stills in some cases) producing a robust note, or column stills yielding a lighter style of spirit, a kaleidoscope of flavours can come from even one distillery. 

The Last Drop distillery has made its name by seeking out small parcels of incredibly rare spirits; its 1976 rum from Jamaica topped the tasting

One such example is the Diamond Distillery in Guyana. Diamond is home to nine different stills, acquired from smaller distillers whose operations were coming to a close: Coffey stills from England; Savalle stills from France; and, most unusually, three wooden stills. Each of these produces a unique spirit, almost akin to having nine distilleries in one. 

It’s not just the stills that have a big impact on flavours but the process that occurs beforehand, too. Fermentation can be a wild affair – literally, with the use of different strains of yeast, and the famed dunder. This leftover liquor from distilling a batch of rum is saved and used to add character to the mix. Typical in rum produced in Jamaica, it imbues the final product with valuable ‘funk’, as it is known.

Finally – and the subject of our tasting here – there are aged rums, arguably the most cerebral of all rums, thanks to a factor that adds further layers of complexity to the end result. Much of the ageing of rum occurs in the country of production, and the impact is often accelerated due to the tropical environment. Rum may also be sent away for further maturation in climates that are not quite as aggressive.

This wide variety of flavours – arising from complex production processes coupled with maturation in a variety of casks across a range of locations – means that rum is a citizen of the world, probably the most worldly spirit there is. Yet there are still plumb lines of quality to be assessed when looking at a rum, no matter where it hails from. Is it immediately identifiable as a rum? Is there balance and complexity? Are the flavours honest and up front? Does the level of sweetness overpower or support the final flavours?

 

El Dorado's Guyanan offering, and Plantation's Barbadian counterpart both scored highly

I was joined by bartender Nate Brown, founder of Merchant House, one of London’s top rum bars, for a look at a global selection of aged rums – whether from independent bottlers that have discovered rare casks in far-flung warehouses, or some of the bigger brands found on the world’s back bars. Noting the key qualities of balance, flavour and personality, we rated each on its own merit. 

‘It was a fascinating exercise,’ says Brown. ‘Being able to focus on each rum, understanding the context of where it came from, how it has evolved through ageing and maturation, and how that presents itself in the glass – this all reveals the depth and diversity of flavour across the aged rum category. There’s a story to discover in every glass.’  Scroll down for our selection of the pick of aged rums from our tasting. 

Scores and notes by Joel Harrison and Nate Brown

Club-Oenologique-magazine-Issue-8

This article is taken from the summer 2021 edition of our quarterly magazine. Each issue focuses on premium wine, spirits and good living, via vivid imagery and insightful articles. Click here to get your copy.

Top Rated Bottles

The best aged rums

The Last Drop, 1976

Score
99
100
Jamaica
  • RRP £3,120
1976
Learn More

Caroni, 1996

Score
98
100
Trinidad
  • RRP £370
1996
Learn More

Dictador, 1976

Score
98
100
Colombia
  • RRP £15,000
1976
Learn More

Chairman’s Reserve, 2005

Score
97
100
Saint Lucia
  • RRP £71
2005
Learn More

Hampden Estate, Overproof

Score
97
100
Jamaica
  • RRP £78
Overproof
Learn More

Monymusk, 2010

Score
97
100
Jamaica
  • RRP £109
2010
Learn More

SBS Brazil, 2011

Score
97
100
Brazil
  • RRP £98.96
2011
Learn More

That Boutique-y Rum Company, Blended Rum #1

Score
97
100
Jamaica
  • RRP £48.95
Blended Rum #1
Learn More

Berry Bros & Rudd, 10-Year-Old Guyana Rum

Score
96
100
Guyana
  • RRP £70
10-Year-Old Guyana Rum
Learn More

Foursquare, Shibboleth

Score
96
100
Barbados
  • RRP £85
Shibboleth
Learn More

Habitation Velier, Last Ward 2007

Score
95
100
Barbados
  • RRP £115
Last Ward 2007
  • Apples
  • Pineapple
  • Spice
Learn More

That Boutique-y Rum Company, Diamond Distillery 18-Year-Old

Score
95
100
Guyana
  • RRP £52
Diamond Distillery 18-Year-Old
Learn More

Cabal, No.1513

Score
94
100
  • RRP £40
No.1513
Learn More

El Dorado, 15-year-old

Score
94
100
Guyana
  • RRP £52
15-year-old
Learn More

Flor de Caña, 25

Score
94
100
Nicaragua
  • RRP £119
25
Learn More

Watt Rum, 13-Year-Old

Score
94
100
Belize
  • RRP £79
13-Year-Old
Learn More

Doorly's, 14-year-old

Score
93
100
Barbados
  • RRP £45
14-year-old
Learn More

Jung & Wulff, No.1

Score
93
100
Trinidad
  • RRP £45
No.1
Learn More

Mount Gay, XO Triple-Cask Blend

Score
93
100
Barbados
  • RRP £54
XO Triple-Cask Blend
Learn More

Plantation, XO

Score
93
100
Barbados
  • RRP £49
XO
Learn More

Ron Zacapa, 23

Score
91
100
Guatemala
  • RRP £45
23
Learn More

Berry Bros & Rudd, 9-year-old

Score
90
100
Mauritius
  • RRP £91.80
9-year-old
Learn More

Ron Zacapa, XO Centenario Solera Gran Reserva Especial

Score
89
100
Guatemala
  • RRP £125
XO Centenario Solera Gran Reserva Especial
Learn More

Santa Teresa, 1796

Score
89
100
Venezuela
  • RRP £44
1796
Learn More

It's even better in print

Get the current issue free when you subscribe for four issues – just enter the code CLUB5 on checkout