glasses and bottles from peter michael winery
The Collection
Wine The Collection 24 November 2021

Peter Michael Winery 2005-2019

Alder Yarrow tastes through library vintages and current releases from the diverse vineyards of California stalwart Peter Michael, including its red and white flagships
Introduction and recommendations by
Alder Yarrow
Photography by

Depending on how much you believe in destiny, it will come as no surprise that when, in 1982, Peter Michael established his eponymous estate winery, it was in Sonoma’s Knights Valley. Seven years later, after a long career as an entrepreneur and technology executive, he was made a sir, making his purchase of 640 steep, rugged acres on the western slopes of Mount St Helena even more apposite.

Raised on Bordeaux and Burgundy, Sir Peter credits the taste of a Chateau Montelena Chardonnay while visiting San Francisco in 1973 as the inspiration to make California wine. Many California wineries have similar origin stories, but they usually feature dreams of making the next great California Cabernet rather than world-class Chardonnay. Sir Peter, it turns out, would go on to do both.

Diminutive in both size and profile, the Knights Valley AVA sits between Napa Valley and Sonoma’s Alexander Valley. Its 2,000 acres of vineyards (Napa has more than 45,000) sit mostly on the narrow valley floor, making the Peter Michael estate on steep volcanic hillsides both a world apart and a marvel of viticultural engineering.

peter michael wine tasting
Peter Michael's two most vaunted wines are the Ma Belle-Fille Chardonnay and the Les Pavots Bordeaux blend, which dates back to 1988

The estate’s 147 acres of vines span five spectacular sites, each producing one of the brand’s flagship bottlings. Les Pavots, with late 1980s plantings of red and white Bordeaux varieties and dotted with its namesake poppies, occupies 64 acres of rolling benchlands at 900–1,400ft of elevation. La Carrière, a 17-acre parcel of Chardonnay sweeps up a steeply curving bowl from 1,200 to 1,700ft, evoking its moniker ‘the quarry’.

Above La Carrière, a rolling plateau of sorts can be found, the right side of which is Mon Plaisir, a 7-acre Chardonnay plot. To the left and above, a stunning, undulant amphitheatre of a further 15.5 acres of Chardonnay rises up to earn its name of Belle Côte (‘beautiful slope’). Up the mountain at 2,000ft above sea level, a staggeringly steep hillside is home to 14 acres of Chardonnay that Sir Peter named Ma Belle-Fille after his daughter-in-law Emily, who has gradually assumed day-to-day stewardship of the estate along with her husband Paul (see p.40). Two additional, equally impressive sites have been acquired over the years: the 400-acre Seaview Estate on the Sonoma Coast (planted to 30 acres of Pinot Noir in 2006 and divided into three vineyards) and a 23-acre vineyard parcel in Napa’s Oakville AVA named Au Paradis.

From these three separate properties, the estate makes a diverse set of wines, united by a vision for expressing the character of what the winery calls mountain viticulture. Steep, rocky, fast-draining slopes with myriad exposures produce wines of power and sometimes surprising elegance. The tasting that follows includes the current vintages of these wines, along with library vintages of its two flagships – Ma Belle-Fille Chardonnay and Les Pavots Bordeaux blend. They were tasted at the winery in the summer of 2021.

The wines

  • Ma Danseuse, Clos du Ciel and Le Caprice
    Separated by blocks of trees, these three plots of Pinot Noir show subtly different expressions of the impressive Seaview Estate, all in a bolder, ripe interpretation of Pinot Noir. Clos du Ciel is the warmest of the three, more sheltered from marine influence, and tends to be richer and riper than Le Caprice, whose steep slopes are slightly more exposed to the sea. Ma Danseuse is the coolest of the sites, with more marine influence and a slight northerly aspect, giving slightly leaner wines.
  • Ma Belle-Fille
    While the highest in elevation (at least until the newest plantings are given a name), this Chardonnay vineyard has the most open exposure to both marine influences and the sun. Consequently, it ripens earliest of all the vineyards, yielding a unique combination of California generosity and an impressive, sometimes racy acidity.
  • Au Paradis
    Acquired in 2007, this vineyard abuts Napa’s famed Dalla Valle estate and merited its own flagship wine from the start. Similar in make-up and style to Les Pavots, perhaps with slightly less chiselled tannins, it is a wine equally built for the long haul.
  • Les Pavots
    One of California’s most esteemed and age-worthy red wines, Les Pavots has bold, ripe flavours and is made in a classically full-bodied California style, balanced by generally excellent acidity and the robust musculature of tannin that often characterises hillside fruit. The Bordeaux blend has been made in every vintage since 1988.

Top Rated Bottles

Peter Michael wines 2005-2019

Peter Michael Winery, L’Après Midi 2018

Score
90
100
Knights Valley AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2025
  • RRP £91.80
L’Après Midi
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Mon Plaisir 2019

Score
95
100
Knights Valley AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2030
  • RRP £118
Mon Plaisir
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Belle Côte 2019

Score
91
100
Knights Valley AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2030
  • RRP £118
Belle Côte
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Ma Belle-Fille 2019

Score
91
100
Knights Valley AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2030
  • RRP £134
Ma Belle-Fille
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Ma Belle-Fille 2018

Score
94
100
Knights Valley AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2028
  • RRP £134
Ma Belle-Fille
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Ma Belle-Fille 2015

Score
93
100
Knights Valley AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2026
  • RRP £134
Ma Belle-Fille
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Ma Belle-Fille 2012

Score
88
100
Knights Valley AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2022
  • RRP £134
Ma Belle-Fille
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Ma Belle-Fille 2009

Score
92
100
Knights Valley AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2023
  • RRP £134
Ma Belle-Fille
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Ma Belle-Fille 2006

Score
92
100
Knights Valley AVA
  • RRP £134
Ma Belle-Fille
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Le Caprice 2016

Score
89
100
Fort Ross-Seaview AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2023
  • RRP £170
Le Caprice
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Ma Danseuse 2016

Score
91
100
Fort Ross-Seaview AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2025
  • RRP £492
Ma Danseuse
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Clos du Ciel 2016

Score
90
100
Fort Ross-Seaview AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2025
  • RRP £377
Clos du Ciel
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Ma Danseuse 2017

Score
92
100
Fort Ross-Seaview AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2028
  • RRP £170
Ma Danseuse
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Au Paradis 2018

Score
96
100
Oakville AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2038
  • RRP £265
Au Paradis
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Les Pavots 2018

Score
95
100
Knights Valley AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2038
  • RRP £265
Les Pavots
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Les Pavots 2012

Score
88
100
Knights Valley AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2022
  • RRP £132
Les Pavots
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Les Pavots 2009

Score
92
100
Knights Valley AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2030
  • RRP £128
Les Pavots
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Les Pavots 2007

Score
95
100
Knights Valley AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2023
  • RRP £132
Les Pavots
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Les Pavots 2006

Score
96
100
Knights Valley AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2030
  • RRP £132
Les Pavots
Learn More

Peter Michael Winery, Les Pavots 2005

Score
98
100
Knights Valley AVA
  • From 2021
  • To 2028
  • RRP £132
Les Pavots
Learn More

Have you joined The Collection yet?

Get access to all our back issues via our free digital archive – and enjoy the best rate on a magazine subscription