An experimental new era for oak in Champagne

Essi Avellan MW charts the rise of the subtle, sophisticated use of oak by Champagne’s leading chefs de caves – and recommends the cuvées best expressing the elegant employment of oak barrels in various shapes and sizes for vinification and maturation

Words by Essi Avellan MW

oak barrel in champagne cellar

It is intriguing to take a look at the use of oak in Champagne based on the wines I tasted for the Champagne Report 2023. Just 20 years ago, oak was a rare sight in a Champagne winery. There were, of course, the classic oak champions who had never jumped on the bandwagon of stainless steel: most notably Krug, Bollinger and Alfred Gratien. But from the 1950s onwards, when most in the region swapped wood for inox containers, the knowhow of oak-vinifications withered and the heritage was all but forgotten. So was production of barrels from Champagne’s own oak forest, Argonne. Back in 1750, there had been a flourishing industry of 150 coopers in Champagne; this slowly died away, with not even one left 30 years ago.

However, a new era began in the 1990s. One of the figureheads of the comeback of oak, Henri Giraud, revived oak production from Argonne with its Fût de Chêne cuvée. Further to this, in 1998 Jérome Viard established his artisan cooperage Tonnellerie de Champagne – and since then the two have teamed up for considerable research into the forgotten oak tree terroirs. The results can be tasted in Fût de Chêne MV 18, which carries a strong stamp of Aÿ Pinot Noir married with the characteristic but harmonious use of oak.

The use of 100% oak vinification can indeed be tricky for a wine as delicate and fine as Champagne and in the early boom years many cuvées appeared heavy-handedly oaky and unbearably oxidative. Small vessels such as the region’s classic 205-litre pièce champenoise are not the easiest to handle. Yet Krug is a master of them; the blended-to-perfection Grande Cuvée 171ème Édition showcases the house’s skill in this area. The wines of Krug stay for just a short period in seasoned barrels, which limits both the oxidative and oaky effect. At Bollinger, the much older barrels hold wines for a significantly longer period. When extreme care is taken to prevent oxidation – for example, through control of evaporation, sulphite levels, topping up and transfer – the resulting micro-oxygenation can have beautiful results. Take the age-defying Bollinger R.D. 2008 as an example.

Leclerc Briant Le Clos des Trois Clochers 2016 carries a more notable mark of oak from vinification in barrel but I found the oak successfully adds to the single-vineyard wine’s singular and racy personality. Site-specific Champagnes do indeed often get support from oak, as exemplified by Lanson’s fine, oak-tinged Clos Lanson 2008.

Partial rather than full oak vinification is the choice of many. Charles Phillipponnat’s era has brought back skilled use of barrels to Philipponnat’s repertoire. Take, for example, the harmonious Cuvée 1522 2015, the prestige cuvée that often sits in the shadow of the mighty Clos des Goisses. Down south in the Aube, Drappier’s famous single-vineyard Champagne Grande Séndree 2012 also successfully gains texture and layers from partial vinification in wood.

Methods of incorporating oak are numerous, as the many variables include the size, origin, toasting and age of the vessel. Also, fermentation or mere maturation in oak produce differing results. Taittinger ages a 5% fraction of Comtes de Champagne base wine in relatively new oak barrels to boost the wine’s hallmark toastiness. Louis Roederer, then again, ferments and ages a part of its prestigious Cristal in large oak vats to ‘open up’ or ‘close down’ the individual plots’ wines to meet the desired style.

Oak is functioning as yet another blending tool for the chef de cave

But prestige bottlings aside, oak is now making a real comeback in non-vintage cuvées too. Alfred Gratien Brut is (and has been since 1864) fully fermented in 228-litre barrels and Bollinger continues to use a partial oak recipe for its complex Special Cuvée blending. Equally, Bruno Paillard has chosen oak to be an integral and consistent part of its Brut Prèmiere Cuvée. Yet there are several houses that have recently added subtle oak influence for their classic cuvées. One will never taste notable oak influence in the richly fruity Veuve Clicquot Yellow Label, luxuriously textured Charles Heidsieck Brut Réserve or vibrantly fresh Lanson Black Création. Here, oak is functioning as yet another blending tool for the chef de cave. This is the direction Louis Roederer is heading in too, as in its latest non-vintage blend, Collection 244, where the traditional 10% oak-matured reserve wines now meet 5% of oak-vat fermented base wines.

The final point at which a chef de cave can fine-tune the wine is at disgorgement and oak can play a role here too. For example, G.H. Mumm is finishing off its Lalou prestige cuvée with dosage liqueur made of oak-aged reserve wine. In this new experimental era, it clearly seems that Champagne is exploring the infinite opportunities afforded by oak.

Top Champagne under the influence of oak

Producer Name Vintage Region Subregion
Champagne Henri Giraud, Fût de Chêne MV18 NV
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Champagne Henri Giraud Fût de Chêne MV18 NV Champagne Champagne AOP
Krug, Grande Cuvée 171ème Édition NV
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Krug Grande Cuvée 171ème Édition NV Champagne Champagne AOP
Bollinger, R.D. 2008
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Bollinger R.D. 2008 Champagne Champagne AOP
Champagne Leclerc Briant, Clos des Trois Clochers Brut 2016
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Champagne Leclerc Briant Clos des Trois Clochers Brut 2016 Champagne Champagne AOP
Maison Lanson, Le Clos Lanson 2008
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Maison Lanson Le Clos Lanson 2008 Champagne Champagne AOP
Philipponnat, Cuvée 1522 2015
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Philipponnat Cuvée 1522 2015 Champagne Champagne AOP
Champagne Drappier, Grande Sendrée 2012
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Champagne Drappier Grande Sendrée 2012 Champagne Champagne AOP
Champagne Taittinger, Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs 2013
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Champagne Taittinger Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs 2013 Champagne Champagne AOP
Louis Roederer, Cristal 2015
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Louis Roederer Cristal 2015 Champagne Champagne AOP
Louis Roederer, Collection 244 NV
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Louis Roederer Collection 244 NV Champagne Champagne AOP
Alfred Gratien, Cuvée Brut NV
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Alfred Gratien Cuvée Brut NV Champagne Champagne AOP
Bollinger, Special Cuvée NV
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Bollinger Special Cuvée NV Champagne Champagne AOP
Champagne Bruno Paillard, Première Cuvée NV
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Champagne Bruno Paillard Première Cuvée NV Champagne Champagne AOP
Veuve Clicquot, Yellow Label Brut NV
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Veuve Clicquot Yellow Label Brut NV Champagne Champagne AOP
Charles Heidsieck, Brut Réserve NV
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Charles Heidsieck Brut Réserve NV Champagne Champagne AOP
Champagne Lanson, Le Black Création 257 NV
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Champagne Lanson Le Black Création 257 NV Champagne Champagne AOP
Champagne G.H. Mumm, RSRV Lalou 2008
Champagne , Champagne AOP
Champagne G.H. Mumm RSRV Lalou 2008 Champagne Champagne AOP