Reports 8 December 2019

Five decades of Watervale Riesling

In a rare tasting with wines dating back to 1977, Nina Caplan discovers why Australian Rieslings are as much loved as their German counterparts

Words by Nina Caplan

Previous Story
Next Story

The persistent ache of homesickness, and the power of wine to assuage it, can have long-lasting effects. In the 19th-century, religious refugees from Silesia arriving in Australia’s Clare Valley looked at those gentle sun-warmed hills and thought it a good idea to plant Riesling. As it turned out, the ocean and the height (400-500m above sea level) provided the requisite cool night air, and the hardscrabble slate and limestone soils made the vines work for their nourishment. The result is that two centuries later these heady, long-lived Rieslings are as much loved as their German counterparts – despite, or in some cases because of, the difference in style.

Jim Barry was one of the first in the modern swathe of Clare winemakers to champion Riesling. In 1964, he planted eight acres in Watervale, just after Leo Buring and John Vickery did the same on their 30-hectare Florita vineyard: those Buring Rieslings would become legendary. (The vineyard had been planted to Palomino and Pedro Ximenez for the fortified wines that were previously Australia’s main output: hence the name – florita refers to the flor that grows on sherry as it ages).

The Florita Vineyard and house in Clare Valley
The Florita Vineyard and house in Clare Valley

In 1986, at a time when Chardonnay was on the rise and Riesling firmly out of fashion, Barry bet his shirt, almost literally, on buying Florita. “Grandma said, on no account buy that vineyard”, his grandson Sam Barry relates, but Sam’s grandfather and then 26-year-old father Peter (pictured above) ignored her advice, believing that in time, people would come back to Riesling. They weren’t able to buy back rights to the name until 2004 and as Sam recalls, “2005 was the first year they didn’t have to sell any grapes!”

Still, the Barrys were right. This tasting goes back through the Florita wines – made from individual rows on a thin covering of terra rossa and loam above limestone, hand-picked at night and destemmed without crushing – to Lodge Hill further north, which has the same vertically cracked slate as Polish Hill, and the Watervale Rieslings that Jim made on clay soils in the early days.

If any proof were needed that top Clare Valley Riesling repays time in bottle, here it is: acidity that softens from imperious to refreshing, flavours that unfurl like flowers in sunlight. These are wines that could reconcile an immigrant to exile: too bad those long-ago Silesians never got to try them.

The wines

Jim Barry, The Florita Riesling, 2017

Score
90
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2023
  • To 2030
  • RRP £28.50
  • Attractive mouthfeel
  • Cool vintage
  • Herbaceous
Learn More

Jim Barry, The Florita Riesling, 2016

Score
91
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2021
  • To 2029
  • RRP £27
  • Citrus
  • Lime
  • Pear
Learn More

Jim Barry, The Florita Riesling, 2014

Score
92
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2019
  • To 2030
  • RRP £55.81
  • Delicately bitter
  • Kerosene
  • Orange flowers
Learn More

Jim Barry, The Florita Riesling, 2013

Score
89
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2022
  • To 2028
  • RRP N/A in UK
  • Bread
  • Lime
  • Toast
Learn More

Jim Barry, The Florita Riesling, 2012

Score
90
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2020
  • To 2026
  • RRP Available in secondary markets
  • Full
  • Textured
  • Young
Learn More

Jim Barry, The Florita Riesling, 2011

Score
89
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2019
  • To 2021
  • RRP £31.50
  • Citrus
  • Mineral
  • Wet slate
Learn More

Jim Barry, The Florita Riesling, 2010

Score
88
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2019
  • To 2022
  • RRP N/A in UK
  • Eucalyptus
  • Herbaceous
  • Mint
Learn More

Jim Barry, The Florita Riesling, 2009

Score
89
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2024
  • To 2030
  • RRP Available in secondary markets
  • Cool
  • Light
  • Pine
Learn More

Jim Barry, The Florita Riesling, 2008

Score
90
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2019
  • To 2021
  • RRP N/A in UK
  • Petrol
  • Rounded
  • Soft
Learn More

Jim Barry, The Florita Riesling, 2007

Score
91
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2019
  • To 2029
  • RRP Available in secondary markets
  • Kerosene
  • Lime
  • White flowers
Learn More

Jim Barry, The Florita Riesling, 2005

Score
90
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2020
  • To 2025
  • RRP 172 (case of 6)
  • Honey
  • Rich
  • Toast
Learn More

Jim Barry, The Florita Riesling, 2004

Score
92
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2019
  • To 2023
  • RRP Available in secondary markets
  • Balanced
  • Elegant
  • Racy
Learn More

Jim Barry, Watervale Riesling, 2004

Score
92
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2020
  • To 2025
  • RRP N/A in UK
  • Fine-grained texture
  • Great acidity
  • Stone fruit
Learn More

Jim Barry, Watervale Riesling, 2002

Score
92
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2019
  • To 2029
  • RRP N/A in UK
  • Lime
  • Petrol
  • Tropical
Learn More

Jim Barry, Watervale Riesling, 1992

Score
90
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2019
  • To 2022
  • RRP N/A in UK
  • Honey
  • Lime
  • White flowers
Learn More

Jim Barry, Watervale Riesling, 1974

Score
94
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2019
  • To 2022
  • RRP N/A in UK
  • Elegant acidity
  • Light sweetness
Learn More

Jim Barry, Lodge Hill Riesling, 1988

Score
90
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2019
  • To 2022
  • RRP N/A in UK
  • Aromatic
  • Deep orange
  • Floral
Learn More

Jim Barry, Lodge Hill Riesling, 1986

Score
89
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2019
  • To 2021
  • RRP N/A in UK
  • Deep orange
  • Energetic
  • Restrained
Learn More

Jim Barry, St Clare Riesling, 1972

Score
82
100
Clare Valley
  • From 2019
  • RRP N/A in UK
  • Honey
  • Savoury
Learn More

Join the Club

Sign up to our newsletter to be the first to read our latest features and reviews, get exclusive offers, and learn about upcoming events.


By signing up to our newsletter you confirm that you have read our Privacy Policy.